How Leaders Can Build Trust With Faculty Experts (opinion)

November 9, 2026
3,782 Views

I’ve never understood why more leaders don’t use the expertise sitting right in front of them. My solution to almost any problem is to find the smartest person I can who has some expertise in the problem I am trying to solve and borrow their brilliance. So, when a colleague at my university published a law review article directly relevant to an administrative problem I was responsible for handling for the university, I did what seemed obvious: I read it, carefully, and emailed her to ask if she had time to talk.

After that conversation, my colleague became genuinely engaged in fixing the relevant issues on campus, contributing her knowledge to work she could just as easily have stood apart from and criticized. I’ve led enough experts to know that’s not the default.

What I’ve come to realize is that accessing someone’s expertise isn’t just good problem-solving. For the brilliant, highly autonomous, challenging people that knowledge organizations depend on—faculty, senior engineers, lawyers, designers, researchers—it’s a fundamental act of leadership. Maybe the most important one.

Why Standard Leadership So Often Fails With Experts

These experts are the highest-stakes people in any knowledge organization. Led well, they produce disproportionate value; led badly, they become the most expensive problem in the organization. They become disengaged or corrosive. Or they simply leave.

Standard leadership advice fails with experts. Traditional rapport-building feels patronizing. Offering autonomy without engagement reads as indifference. Praise from someone they don’t respect lands as noise. Platitudes or calls for town halls or committees to study a problem can all be worse than nothing, because experts can tell the difference between performance and real action. Leaders often conclude these people are simply difficult, brilliant weirdos and toxic geniuses. But what is actually happening is that your highest performers are running a specific and entirely rational assessment of whether you have the standing to lead them at all.

The question they’re asking is not whether you’re a good leader in the abstract. It’s whether you understand their work well enough to see them accurately—and whether your evaluation of what they do therefore means anything at all.

The Epistemic Threshold

Most leaders have never thought about trust this way. We have been taught to think about trust as relational, built through consistency, transparency and follow-through. All that still matters with experts, but it’s not sufficient. Before the relational trust can even begin to accumulate, there’s an epistemic threshold to clear.

Early in my career, before I had a framework for any of this, I learned this the hard way. I was the freshly hired Ph.D. at a design and technology firm. I was the egghead academic whom others tolerated but did not quite trust. Then I did something that impressed them: I pulled years of customer help requests and analyzed them the way I would analyze research data, treating a practical business problem like a scholarly one.

Suddenly, colleagues who had been skeptical of what I brought to the table were willing to follow my lead. Even more amazing, they trusted me to lead not just on research questions, but on design decisions and project management, things I was honestly less qualified to weigh in on. The credibility I’d established in one domain gave me standing in others. That’s the mechanism working in an expertise-driven organization: You demonstrate you understand the work, and people extend you trust they wouldn’t have otherwise given.

I’ve now watched this mechanism play out across three decades and three very different organizations—a consulting firm, a tech start-up and a research university. In each context, the moment when a leader demonstrated genuine engagement with what an expert actually did—not performed interest, not generic praise, but real comprehension—was the moment the relationship changed. The change is not always dramatic; in fact, it is often subtle, but what happens in this moment is that the expert, your super-high performing employee, stops holding back. They stop relating to leadership and administration as people to be navigated around and start treating them as worth engaging with fully.

One of my closest friends studies how organizations actually work. She deeply understands all the unspoken rules and the way power really moves. She’s also a mother with kids close to the ages of my own, which means half our conversations happen between school pickups or while waiting for a children’s theater production to start, and the rest happen because I call her whenever I’m stuck. This is not a symbolic performance of humility—I call her because her knowledge makes me better and she knows things I don’t. Treating the expertise around you as a resource rather than a credential to be applauded and set aside is not a technique. It’s a way of being, and it requires maintenance.

How to Earn Experts’ Trust

  • Do the intellectual work before you ask anything. Read the paper. Understand the code base. Learn the case law. Not to demonstrate that you did it but to actually do it. This population has finely calibrated detectors for performance over substance, and they will know the difference. The goal is not to signal engagement. The goal is to be engaged.
  • When you recognize expertise, be specific. Don’t just say, “Great work.” Instead, say something like “The argument you made in the third section changed how I’m thinking about X.” Generic praise from someone without standing is worse than silence. Specific recognition from someone who demonstrably understands the work is the thing this population needs the most.
  • Treat your own credibility as something that erodes. It is not a credential you earn once and can spend indefinitely. The leaders who fail with this population often had genuine standing at some point, but they stopped doing the work to maintain it—e.g., the dean who hasn’t published in a decade. Recognize that the criteria by which these experts judge you doesn’t disappear when you stop doing the work.

The experts in your organization are not waiting for a better manager. They’re waiting for someone who understands what they do well enough to lead them: to see them accurately, challenge them credibly and earn the kind of trust that can’t be assigned or assumed.

Gillian R. Hayes is a Chancellor’s Professor and the Robert A. and Barbara L. Kleist Professor of Informatics in the Donald Bren School of Information and Computer Sciences and the vice provost of academic personnel at the University of California, Irvine. Her research focuses on the design and evaluation of community-based digital technologies in education and health care.



Source by [author_name]

You may be interested

Kansas City Current capture first NWSL trophy in 2-1 win over Washington Spirit
Top Stories
shares2,258 views
Top Stories
shares2,258 views

Kansas City Current capture first NWSL trophy in 2-1 win over Washington Spirit

new admin - Nov 22, 2026

The Kansas City Current made history Saturday, capturing their first NWSL Championship title in a thrilling 2-1 victory over the…

Audacious train theft ring in California films multimillion-dollar robberies
Top Stories
shares3,290 views
Top Stories
shares3,290 views

Audacious train theft ring in California films multimillion-dollar robberies

new admin - Nov 22, 2026

A ring of thieves allegedly targeted dozens of freight trains in Southern California, stealing more than $22 million in merchandise…

Athlete swims Strait of Hormuz to raise awareness of Iran war’s toll on wildlife
Top Stories
shares3,237 views
Top Stories
shares3,237 views

Athlete swims Strait of Hormuz to raise awareness of Iran war’s toll on wildlife

new admin - Nov 22, 2026

British endurance swimmer Lewis Pugh has swum in the North Pole and Antarctica to draw attention to environmental causes. But…