Student Success and Public Trust

November 20, 2026
2,986 Views

The wisdom of crisis communications says: “If you’re explaining, you’re losing.” In the crisis of lost public trust in higher ed, too many institutions are explaining. Colleges defend their value with broad claims about lifetime earnings and graduate success. By offering counterpoints to critics, they validate the claims that college isn’t worthwhile, and their defenses fall flat with the millions of stopped out students for whom higher ed’s promises were broken. Instead of attempts to “change the narrative,” colleges need to prove that higher education is worth students’ time and money. Student success initiatives are perhaps the strongest piece of evidence colleges have to show they care about students’ futures.

At Inside Higher Ed’s annual Student Success US conference in Salt Lake City this week, a few things became apparent: Student success leaders clearly see students’ unique needs and learning goals. These administrators are not shy about naming higher ed’s failures to support students. They own those shortcomings and, despite thin staffing and minimal funds, their departments persist in coming up with new ways to address them.

The student success leaders in Utah told hard truths. They acknowledged that many of their institutions aren’t designed with students’ needs in mind—support services are only available from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.; disjointed points of service have students running laps around campus, from the bursar to the financial aid office, to get answers to urgent questions. Institutions send too many emails, issue too many surveys and don’t use data effectively, administrators said. Faculty are often not included in student success conversations, they observed. Leaders grieved the students who drop out after the first semester when they can’t pay their first tuition bill.

But at the event, these admissions came paired with solutions, however small. The director of basic needs at a large public university found that 90 percent of students who received emergency aid enrolled in the next semester. Of those who got no aid, just 20 percent persisted. Committed to keeping more students enrolled, she launched a fundraising campaign specifically for emergency funds.

This is one example of how institutions are trying to support students with interventions. Others target food insecurity and meeting students’ housing and childcare needs. Complete College America (CCA) this week published a basic needs support guide for the growing number of institutions—from community colleges to large research universities— developing these programs. Meeting students’ basic needs is “the next frontier of the completion agenda,” Yolanda Watson Spiva, president of CCA, said in a release about the report. “Successfully addressing these needs ensures that students with increasingly diverse ages, work experiences and family responsibilities can find a path to and through college.”

Basic needs interventions are just one way student success administrators are helping students get through college. Others described their tactics for untangling institutional bureaucracies for students. When the University of Utah, our event host, identified gaps in how students navigate campus services, its student success leaders worked with students and staff to develop Answer U, a student support system that connects learners to career coaching, financial aid and scholarships, and academic advising. Mitzi Montoya, the university’s provost and executive vice president for academic affairs, said the system saves students from going from office to office to get information. Students’ questions also give her team real-time information on what they’re struggling with. “[We] understand where we need to redesign systems and processes because the answers are not easy to find,” she said at the conference. “And we now have a whole series of other projects related to it.”

Administrators also recognized that support services must adapt to students’ unique needs and learning goals. Academic advising for an 18-year-old is different from what a returning adult student needs, for example. And while lawmakers might equate higher ed’s value with graduate jobs and salaries, data from 55,000 students in the National Survey of Student Engagement’s (NSSE) Career & Workforce Module undercuts those assumptions. Students ranked expected job salary and availability fourth among the items that influence their career plans. Both first year and senior students said the factors that influence their career plans more are: Finding a job that fits their interests and abilities; a desire to make a difference in their community; and wanting to make an impact on society. Jillian Kinzie, associate director of the Indiana University Center for Postsecondary Research and the NSSE Institute, said the findings are a “serious” indication that students’ career goals are driven by their passions and desire to make a difference. “Two things to keep top of mind [for higher ed institutions] are: What are students looking for? And then, how are we going to communicate our larger responsibility to ensure employment and earnings together?” Kinzie told administrators.

Despite the initiatives and energy on display this week, student success can only go so far. Many of the problems contributing to America’s declining opinion about higher education require more systemic change. Colleges and universities are still perceived as too expensive and too many institutions are not transparent about cost. In our recent Student Voice survey of more than 5,000 students, just a quarter were highly confident their college or university is taking meaningful steps toward affordability, such as reducing unnecessary costs, limiting tuition increases or pooling resources. And just 29 percent fully grasp the total cost of attendance, beyond tuition. Student success leaders can’t communicate the impact of academic research or protect the public funding needed to sustain it, either. And while they can create mentoring programs to help students maintain academic momentum and provide teaching and learning training to faculty, student success leaders can’t change academic incentive structures that reward research over teaching, or control whether a curriculum is relevant to employers.

A first step to rebuild trust in higher education is admitting that too many students fall through the cracks—a reality the student success leaders readily acknowledged in Utah this week. As those administrators return to their campuses with new ideas and renewed energy for their work, I hope they have the full support of their institutions. Student success leaders can spearhead initiatives that show a skeptical public that colleges want their students to thrive, but they can’t do it alone.

Sara Custer is editor in chief at Inside Higher Ed.



Source by [author_name]

You may be interested

2026 NWSL Championship between Washington Spirit and KC Current exemplifies growth of women’s soccer
Top Stories
shares2,429 views
Top Stories
shares2,429 views

2026 NWSL Championship between Washington Spirit and KC Current exemplifies growth of women’s soccer

new admin - Nov 20, 2026

Women's professional sports have been on a winning streak for years — from triumphs on the world's biggest stages to…

Anthropic mathematician claims to have solved prestigious Millennium Prize problem with Claude
Technology
shares2,593 views
Technology
shares2,593 views

Anthropic mathematician claims to have solved prestigious Millennium Prize problem with Claude

new admin - Nov 20, 2026

I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof1 of the Riemann Hypothesis. In fact, the method easily extends…

Man who plotted to assassinate Sikh political dissident in NYC is sentenced to more than 19 years in prison
Top Stories
shares3,272 views
Top Stories
shares3,272 views

Man who plotted to assassinate Sikh political dissident in NYC is sentenced to more than 19 years in prison

new admin - Nov 20, 2026

An Indian national accused of plotting to assassinate a prominent political dissident in New York City, allegedly at the behest…