How Will Trump’s New Rule Change Programmatic Accreditation?

November 20, 2026
3,686 Views

For years, Republican policymakers have been concerned about what some describe as a “cozy relationship” between accreditors and the trade groups they represent, arguing that it creates a glaring conflict of interest that breeds unnecessary evaluation standards, credential inflation and higher college costs.

Now, as the Trump administration implements new federal regulations and tries to crack down on what it alleges are antitrust violations, experts say certain accreditors could face significant changes. Some agencies are already planning to formally end their scrutinized partnerships in order to comply with the new rule, which takes effect in July.

Earlier this month, the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) and its related accrediting body—the AVMA Council on Education—announced plans to become fully separate entities; the Association of Theological Schools is also planning to separate from its accrediting arm, the Commission on Accrediting.

Such quality assurance agencies, known as programmatic accreditors, can help specific types of degree programs—as opposed to entire institutions—access federal student aid and other government grants. But they must meet regulatory standards and be federally recognized in order to do so. Over the years, many programmatic accreditors have also become pivotal in the state licensure process for their given profession. (Students often just have to graduate from a program accredited by a specific agency to qualify for a license, but in some cases the agency also has to be federally recognized.)

For the colleges and accreditors that do require federal recognition to access aid or licensure, the new regulations effectively raise the bar they have to clear to prove “separation and independence” from any related trade groups.

This means that if programmatic agencies want to stay in ED’s good graces, they will no longer be able to depend on the larger, better-resourced professional associations for funding, staff, technology or office space. Nor will they be allowed to accept association members as volunteers on the committees that vote to determine their accreditation standards.

The separate and independent changes also apply to institutional accreditors, which comprehensively evaluate colleges and universities, but those agencies likely won’t have to make as many changes to prove they are independent.

One programmatic agency heavily targeted by the rule change is the American Bar Association’s Council of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions, which Trump’s executive order directly called on to “reform accreditation.” It was also sharply criticized at a recent Education Department panel. Many higher education experts argue the Council works too closely with ABA’s governing board, but the Trump administration has also targeted ABA for culture war issues, including its diversity equity and inclusion standards. So far, the ABA has made a few changes to its accreditation standards, but has not publicly announced any plans to restructure along the lines of AVMA or ATS.

And while both conservative and liberal consumer protection advocates largely agree that ABA and the programmatic accrediting system in general is crawling with antitrust violations, some on the left worry that the Trump administration’s approach to addressing this issue has become overly politicized and won’t be as effective as originally hoped. The rule will force many agencies to reshape their infrastructure or opt out of federal recognition, experts said, but it’s unclear if those changes will truly end the trade group’s influence on accreditation.

“Like what a lot of the Trump administration does, there is a kernel of a good idea buried under a mountain of bad policy here,” said Jeremy Bauer-Wolf, the higher education investigations manager at New America, a left-leaning think tank.

“The idea that there is too much collusion, as the administration puts it, or too much overlap between industry and accreditors is a very real and valid criticism,” Bauer-Wolf added. “But my question becomes: Do you want your posture to be, meet these very specific and sometimes overbearing rules or exit the system? I don’t know if that’s the proper posture.”

‘Consequential Decisions’

No veterinary schools depend on the AVMA’s Council on Education for access to student loans as they are all housed at larger universities with an institutional accreditor that serves as the link. But they do depend on the programmatic agency for access to certain research grants and loan repayment programs. And currently, 49 of the 62 veterinary licensure boards in the U.S. and Canada mention AVMA accreditation and/or federal recognition in their statutes.

These dependencies appear to be a driving factor behind why AVMA and the Council are parting ways, according to a news release that explains the separation, although AVMA also warns that doing so will likely be a costly endeavor.

Currently, AVMA subsidizes about 50 percent of the Council’s accreditation expenses. Under the new rule, that subsidy will no longer be possible, and colleges will have to bear the burden and other new overhead costs through their accreditation dues.

Inside Higher Ed reached out to AVMA for comment but the association declined, saying the new regulations “and their interpretation are still developing.” The group said it could say more after the Education Department releases its Accreditation Handbook “in early 2027.”

Emma Read, CEO of the American Association of Veterinary Medical Colleges, which has also served as a key partner for the AVMA Council on Education, noted that the loss of trade association members voting on accreditation standards will result in a lack of expertise. That absence of insight, she said, could lead to lower quality education and greater logistical challenges for the institutions implementing new policies.

“Who better to understand what it will mean to put a standard in place than the people that actually have to put the standard in place?” Read said. “But we recognize that the department has decided against that. So while our faculty and staff will put ideas forward and propose standard changes … we recognize we won’t have any part in that decision-making.”

Zach Waymer, executive director of the Association of Specialized and Professional Accreditors (ASPA), the association that represents programmatic accreditors, said he’s particularly concerned about the “extremely constrained timeframe” agencies have been given to make those decisions; he is not convinced the rushed implementation of new regulations will have Trump’s desired effect in squashing trade groups’ influence. The rule was finalized in late October.

“These are consequential decisions with financial, operational, and potential legal implications that take time and cost money,” Waymer said.

By sharing resources with trade associations, accreditors have been able to keep costs down and stay “at the forefront of expertise from the field,” he added. It didn’t mean that the trade group itself was making decisions for the accreditor.

“These are time and costs that spill over into programs, institutions, and even, indirectly, students,” he said. “The Department hasn’t demonstrated how these changes will improve educational quality or student outcomes.”

Impact ‘Hard to Gauge’

Not all of the roughly 30 programmatic accreditors currently recognized by the Education Department have decided to formally turn their existing accreditation arms into a new nonprofit like AVMA or ATS. At least seven have opted to withdraw from federal recognition, citing issues with the new accreditation rules.

One, the Council on Chiropractic Education, explained in an FAQ that it withdrew because Trump’s new rule included “excessively burdensome and unnecessary standards” and “weakened the peer-review process.”

Critics of Trump’s policy are most worried about these groups. When an accreditor withdraws, the federal government loses its ability to hold the accreditor accountable. But sacrificing federal recognition doesn’t prevent an accreditor from evaluating colleges for other purposes, like state licensure eligibility.

“The real impact of those changes over time is a little hard to gauge at the moment, and it’s going to depend on whether or not these agencies remain in federal recognition,” said Antoinette Flores, vice president of federal policy at the Council for Higher Education Accreditation. “I think there’s an open question about whether or not making an accrediting agency be in a different building than a trade association is going to stop credential inflation and other problems we are seeing, particularly if agencies are pulling out of federal recognition altogether.”

Still, conservatives and the Trump administration have held fast to the argument that trade groups have an “outsized and direct influence” on accreditors’ decisions, which has to be addressed. They highlight AVMA as a prime example.

In 2025, the Department of Justice backed Lincoln Memorial University and its vet school in an antitrust lawsuit against AVMA. LMU took issue with the accreditation council’s requirement that institutions “maintain substantial research activities,” which are costly. The university argued in the suit that by setting this standard, the association was seeking to “make veterinary medicine a more profitable endeavor.” The lawsuit was eventually dismissed, but the DOJ argued that professional associations that “promulgate” and “enforce” accreditation standards are not exempt from antitrust laws.

“By imposing exclusionary restrictions, accreditors and occupational and professional licensors can artificially limit the supply of service providers, thus reducing output, competition, and incentives for innovation,” the department said. “This ultimately harms consumers, who face higher costs and fewer choices in service providers.”

Diane Auer Jones, a long-time critic of programmatic accreditors who served in the Education Department under both George W. Bush and the first Trump administration, added that the partnership between agencies and trade groups wasn’t always a problem. But now that they’ve transformed from voluntary systems of peer-review to “gatekeepers” who can prevent access to state licenses, professional associations have too much control.

Ideally, Auer Jones would like to see the Education Department strip programmatic accreditors of federal recognition altogether.

“Institutional accrediting agencies cannot be permitted to hold monopolies over entry to entire occupations or fields,” she said. Ending federal recognition across the board would require accreditors “to work with states and reopen multiple pathways to licensure eligibility,” which is “the most important next step the Secretary must take.”



Source by [author_name]

You may be interested

Teenage Engineering’s first CD player puts the spinning disc on display
Technology
shares2,250 views
Technology
shares2,250 views

Teenage Engineering’s first CD player puts the spinning disc on display

new admin - Nov 20, 2026

Teenage Engineering announced what it describes as “a modern take on a classic CD player” with its new EP/BC–1 featuring…

2026 NWSL Championship between Washington Spirit and KC Current exemplifies growth of women’s soccer
Top Stories
shares2,433 views
Top Stories
shares2,433 views

2026 NWSL Championship between Washington Spirit and KC Current exemplifies growth of women’s soccer

new admin - Nov 20, 2026

Women's professional sports have been on a winning streak for years — from triumphs on the world's biggest stages to…

Anthropic mathematician claims to have solved prestigious Millennium Prize problem with Claude
Technology
shares2,594 views
Technology
shares2,594 views

Anthropic mathematician claims to have solved prestigious Millennium Prize problem with Claude

new admin - Nov 20, 2026

I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof1 of the Riemann Hypothesis. In fact, the method easily extends…