Ky. AG, UofL Foundation Seek to Defy Dead Donors’ Wishes
The University of Louisville Foundation and the commonwealth of Kentucky’s Republican attorney general have been asking judges to let the foundation defy the wishes of deceased donors who established scholarships specifically for Black and female students. They say going against their desires is necessary to prevent the complete end of the scholarships they established.
The foundation cited Kentucky’s diversity, equity and inclusion ban, passed last year, that generally says scholarships can’t have race- or sex-based restrictions. Attorney General Russell Coleman’s office says both that law, known as House Bill 4, and the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling ending affirmative action in college admissions make the restrictions illegal.
Together, the foundation and AG have asked for at least five scholarships from late donors to be opened up to students of all races and sexes, arguing that this would allow them to be preserved. One county judge approved removing restrictions from four scholarships that said they must go to women, but another county judge rejected removing the requirement that the fifth scholarship go to Black students. Two Louisville community groups have lined up to preserve that restriction, but they’ve employed legal arguments that could end the scholarship completely.
“We do not want these scholarships to end,” said Sadiqa Reynolds, one of the attorneys for the community groups and a former University of Louisville Board of Trustees member. She said she doesn’t think they’re legally required to end or change. But, she said, “if they are ended, they must be spent [down] for the populations they are designated for.”
Louisville Public Media first reported on the string of cases, based on information uncovered by James Orlick, a University of Louisville Ph.D. candidate who’s been researching HB 4. Since the article published Friday, criticism of the effort has mounted. The community groups filed a friend of-the-court brief saying the foundation’s and AG’s legal arguments don’t hold water. The university, for its part, has tried to distance itself from the foundation—though its president and five university Board of Trustees members are on the foundation board.
The foundation itself didn’t provide interviews Wednesday. A spokesperson emailed Inside Higher Ed a statement from Executive Director and Chief Operating Officer Keith Sherman, saying the foundation has, “wherever possible,” worked “with donors or their heirs to make the necessary changes.”
“For a very small number of endowments where no heirs were available to approve changes, the Foundation sought guidance and approval from Jefferson Circuit Court through a process established under Kentucky law,” Sherman said. “The purpose of that action was straightforward: to allow these scholarships to continue supporting students rather than leaving the funds unable to be distributed.”
The community groups’ amicus brief argues the scholarships are legally allowed to wind down by giving out all their money to Black and female students as intended.
“As awards are paid from the corpus [of financial investments], the balance declines to zero,” attorneys for the community groups write. But they’ve also argued that a “fund can be transferred to a qualified private entity that can administer it for Black students.” (Conservative activists have also targeted private scholarship-granting entities, including the Hispanic Scholarship Fund, alleging their race, ethnicity and sex restrictions are illegal.)
The AG’s office has said race- and sex-based scholarship restrictions are being removed across the state, though it’s unclear how many were set by deceased donors. In a footnote in one court filing, the office wrote that “multiple public postsecondary education institutions have requested the Attorney General’s consent to make similar amendments to scholarships” since HB 4 passed, and added that the private Bellarmine University also “sought approval for a similar modification because it believes the discrimination that the scholarship required is unconstitutional under federal law.”
A Bellarmine spokesperson told Inside Higher Ed on Wednesday in an email that “because the donors of these scholarship funds have passed away, only the court can modify the relevant language under state law.”
Legal Wrangling
Much of the public and legal disagreement is over the meaning of an exemption HB 4 provides for “endowments for privately funded scholarships that existed before June 27, 2025 … until the balance of corpus is exhausted.” The AG and community groups also disagree over the relevance or irrelevance of the 2023 Supreme Court ruling that banned affirmative action specifically in admissions—not scholarships.
Over all, it’s another fight over whether institutions are simply complying or overcomplying with DEI bans, and another example of Republicans attempting to expand the impact of the Supreme Court decision beyond admissions. (When the Trump administration’s Department of Justice issued guidance last year saying race-based scholarships are illegal, it cited the high court’s ruling among its justifications.)
The highest-profile case centers on the Newmark scholarship, which supports Black medical school students; AG Coleman and the foundation lost at the county circuit court level, and the AG’s office appealed.
When Lucile Newmark died in 1952—a few years before the Brown v. Board of Education decision declared racial segregation in schools illegal—she left money in her will to the university for “colored students who may be entered in the Medical School.” The foundation and AG asked Jefferson County Circuit Court to lift that racial restriction, but were denied by Judge Eric J. Haner in two curt rulings that questioned in part whether attorneys sufficiently read HB 4.
Haner’s orders, which run less than five pages, said the foundation didn’t even address the legislation’s exemption in its petition, or at a hearing.
“If the Foundation was truly interested in abiding by Ms. Newmark’s ‘charitable purpose’ as alleged, and it was truly concerned with being sued due to the new law, then it stands to reason that it would have considered instead filing a petition to ensure that it could rely on this exemption to continue to administer the scholarship funds as it has done,” he wrote.
He added, “The Court is uncertain if the Foundation and the Attorney General’s office just simply failed to read the law, or whether they engaged in willful obfuscation. While curious, the Court will exercise judicial restraint by not requiring the parties to appear before it to explain their positions, in the hope that this will be a lesson for what is not to occur in the future.”
Now, the Louisville Urban League and Falls City Medical Society, a group of doctors of African descent, are seeking to defend the lower-court opinion. In a brief filed with the appeals court on their behalf, Reynolds and fellow attorney Ramon McGee urged the university and foundation to honor the donor’s intent.
“We also encourage them to get off their knees and fight for Black students,” they wrote in a joint statement.
A Disputed Exemption
Many scholarship funds, including the Newmark scholarship, are meant to be permanent—providing awards to students based on investment income and purposefully never depleting their investments. HB 4, however, can be read as forcing permanent scholarships with race- and sex-based restrictions to spend down their investments, unless they can find some way out of the restrictions.
In its appeals court filing, the AG’s office says, “The key language is ‘until the balance of [the] corpus is exhausted.’”
“This language unambiguously puts a time limit on the … exception … it does not apply to a corpus that will never be exhausted,” the AG’s attorneys wrote. They said, “The legislature gave a university with a violative scholarship a choice: the university can exhaust the corpus of the scholarship or, as the UofL Foundation is seeking to do, the university can change the scholarship to remove the race-based restriction.”
The AG’s office argues that’s more in line with what Newmark wanted than exhausting the investments. The attorneys for the Louisville community groups disagree.
“She placed no restriction on spending the principal,” they wrote.
“Ms. Newmark did not make a general gift to the Medical School,” they wrote. “Writing in 1952, she directed her gift to Black medical students facing racial barriers to the profession. Removing the beneficiary restriction while [HB 4] permits the gift to be carried out as written would defeat, rather than honor, her charitable purpose.”
Haner also wrote in his orders that the foundation has the discretion to spend down the investments supporting the Newmark scholarship “in a way that ensures that the balance of its corpus will be exhausted.”
But Reynolds told Inside Higher Ed she further believes the Newmark scholarship can legally both keep its race restriction and keep operating for a long time. HB 4 doesn’t define when the corpus must be exhausted.
“Wind down in 100 years? That’s still a date. Wind down in 500 years? That’s still a date. Wind down when the world is equitable and fair?” Reynolds said.
Complicating things further, the university provided its own legal two cents in a long email it sent to the university community Monday responding to “concern and confusion” and the LPM article. The email says early on that “the UofL Foundation is a separate entity from the university,” that “the university’s Office of University Counsel does not control or approve the foundation’s legal filings” and that “HB 4, standing alone, would actually allow most existing race-based and gender-based scholarships to remain in place.”
But the email then says, “The university’s analysis does not stop with state law,” goes on to reference the 2023 Supreme Court case on admissions and says the university has “received formal notification that its administration of certain benefits with race-based and gender-based criteria is under federal review.”
In July 2025, the Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights said it had received a complaint alleging the university discriminates based on “race, color, or national origin by offering, promoting or administering” six scholarships. The Newmark scholarship wasn’t among them. OCR said it was investigating; that probe’s current status is unclear
You may be interested

Anthropic’s 7 co-founders are worth about $20 billion each in record IPO payday. Here’s who they are.
new admin - Nov 19, 2026Anthropic's seven co-founders are in for a massive payday. Each of Anthropic's co-founders is now worth about $20 billion, based on…

Palestinians flee and Gaza ceasefire tested as Israeli tanks cross ‘yellow line’
new admin - Nov 19, 2026They said a warning had been issued to civilians in the area prior to the operation, though they did not…

The Restless Storytelling at the Heart of the Grateful Dead
new admin - Nov 19, 2026[ad_1] In the 2023 book Quantum Criminals, journalist Alex Pappademas and artist Joan LeMay gave us a front row seat…





























