AI Detection Tools Are Powerful When Instructors Know How to Use Them

April 8, 2025
3,815 Views

To the editor:

I’m sympathetic to the overall thrust of Steven Mintz’s argument in Inside Higher Ed, “Writing in the Age of AI Suspicion” (April 2, 2025). AI-detection programs are unreliable. To the degree that instructors rely on AI detection, they contribute to the erosion of trust between instructors and students—not a good thing. And because AI “detection” works by assessing things like the smoothness or “fluency” in writing, they implicitly invert our values: We are tempted to have higher regard for less structured or coherent writing, since it strikes us as more authentic.

Mintz’s article is potentially misleading, however. He repeatedly testifies that in testing the detection software, his and other non-AI-produced writing yielded certain scores as “percent AI generated.” For instance, he writes, “27.5 percent of a January 2019 piece … was deemed likely to contain AI-generated text.” Although the software Mintz used for this exercise (ZeroGPT) does claim to identify “how much” of the writing it flags as AI-generated, many other AI detectors (e.g., chatgptzero) indicate rather the degree of probability that the writing as a whole was written by AI. Both types of data are imperfect and problematic, but they communicate different things.

Again, Mintz’s argument is useful. But if conscientious instructors are going to take a stand against technologies on empirical or principled grounds, they will do well to demonstrate appreciation for the nuances of the various tools. 

Christopher Richmann is the associate director of the Academy for Teaching and Learning and affiliate faculty in the Department of Religion at Baylor University.



Source by [author_name]

You may be interested

Two Dallas sisters among the dozens killed in Central Texas flooding
Top Stories
shares3,880 views
Top Stories
shares3,880 views

Two Dallas sisters among the dozens killed in Central Texas flooding

new admin - Jul 06, 2025

Two sisters from Dallas — 13-year-old Blair Harber and 11-year-old Brooke Harber — were among the dozens of lives lost in…

Renewed momentum for Israel-Hamas ceasefire in Gaza
Top Stories
shares2,330 views
Top Stories
shares2,330 views

Renewed momentum for Israel-Hamas ceasefire in Gaza

new admin - Jul 06, 2025

Renewed momentum for Israel-Hamas ceasefire in Gaza - CBS News Watch CBS News Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he…

Ozzy Osbourne, Black Sabbath’s Back to the Beginning: Concert Review
Music
shares3,596 views
Music
shares3,596 views

Ozzy Osbourne, Black Sabbath’s Back to the Beginning: Concert Review

new admin - Jul 06, 2025

[ad_1] “Let the madness begin!” bellowed a mischievous Ozzy Osbourne from his bat-and-skull encrusted throne in front of a sold-out Villa Park…