Poker Face season 2 is coming to Peacock this May

Poker Face’s first season was one of the best arguments to sign up for a Peacock subscription, and the show’s upcoming second season looks like it’s going to be even more of a blast.

Poker Face season 2 brings Charlie Cale (Natasha Lyonne) back for another round of Columbo-esque murder mystery solving, and a new trailer for the series teases how she’s once again going to be putting her unusual ability to tell when people are lying to good use. Like the last season, the next batch of Poker Face’s episodes will feature a cavalcade of celebrity guest stars like Cynthia Erivo, Katie Holmes, Giancarlo Esposito, Method Man, and John Mulaney — who seems to be playing an FBI agent.

The trailer doesn’t really give you all that many clues as to which of its new characters might be killers Charlie has to sniff out. But it does let us know that Poker Face will be making its triumphant return on May 8th.